MANU/SC/1411/2022
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Appeal No. 1441 of 2022
Decided On: 31.10.2022
Appellants: The State of Jharkhand Vs. Respondent: Shailendra Kumar Rai
Hon'ble Judges/Coram:Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud and Hima Kohli JUDGMENTDr. D.Y. Chandrachud, JTable of Contents A. Background i. An overview of the testimonies of the witnesses examined by the prosecution a. Lallan Prasad, PW 11 b. Dr. R.K. Pandey, PW 6 c. Dr. Minu Mukherjee, PW 9 d. Dr. R. Mahto, PW 8 e. Suresh Yadav, PW 12 f. Rekha Dasgupta, PW 7 g. Hostile witnesses ii. An overview of the testimonies of the witnesses examined by the defence a. Dhirendra Rai, DW 1 b. Dasrath Tiwary, DW 2 c. Balmukund Rai, DW 3 iii. The decision of the Sessions Court iv. The High Court's judgment on appeal B. Issues C. Submissions D. Analysis i. The statement of the deceased is relevant Under Section 32(1) of the Indian Evidence Act 1872 a. The vi........
JUDGMENT
Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, J
Table of Contents
A. Background i. An overview of the testimonies of the witnesses examined by the prosecution a. Lallan Prasad, PW 11 b. Dr. R.K. Pandey, PW 6 c. Dr. Minu Mukherjee, PW 9 d. Dr. R. Mahto, PW 8 e. Suresh Yadav, PW 12 f. Rekha Dasgupta, PW 7 g. Hostile witnesses ii. An overview of the testimonies of the witnesses examined by the defence a. Dhirendra Rai, DW 1 b. Dasrath Tiwary, DW 2 c. Balmukund Rai, DW 3 iii. The decision of the Sessions Court iv. The High Court's judgment on appeal B. Issues C. Submissions D. Analysis i. The statement of the deceased is relevant Under Section 32(1) of the Indian Evidence Act 1872 a. The vi........
A.
Background
i.
An overview of the testimonies of the witnesses examined by the prosecution
a.
Lallan Prasad, PW 11
b.
Dr. R.K. Pandey, PW 6
c.
Dr. Minu Mukherjee, PW 9
d.
Dr. R. Mahto, PW 8
e.
Suresh Yadav, PW 12
f.
Rekha Dasgupta, PW 7
g.
Hostile witnesses
ii.
An overview of the testimonies of the witnesses examined by the defence
Dhirendra Rai, DW 1
Dasrath Tiwary, DW 2
Balmukund Rai, DW 3
iii.
The decision of the Sessions Court
iv.
The High Court's judgment on appeal
B.
Issues
C.
Submissions
D.
Analysis
The statement of the deceased is relevant Under Section 32(1) of the Indian Evidence Act 1872
The vi........