SC 4349 , 2020 (6 )ALD176 , 2021 (144 ) ALR 780 , 2020 (5 )ALT172 , 2021 1 AWC940 SC , 2020 (6 )BLJ(SC )352 , 2020 (4 ) CCC 69 (SC ), 2021 (5 )CTC120 , 2020 (II )CLR(SC)834 , 2021 (1 )ICC520 (SC ), ILR[2020 ]MP2016 , 2020 INSC 551 , 2020 (4 )JLJ1 , 2021 -1 -LW485 , 2021 (3 )MhLj242 , (2020 )7 MLJ366 , 2021 (2 )MPLJ36 , 2021 (3 ) MWN 601 , 2020 (II )OLR756 , 2020 (4 )RCR(Civil)428 , 2021 151 RD134 , (2020 )9 SCC510 , 2020 (9-10 ) SCJ 293 , [2020 ]11 SCR268 , ,MANU/SC/0694/2020Ashok Bhushan#R. Subhash Reddy#M.R. Shah#312SC4520Judgment/OrderAIC#AIR#ALD#ALR#ALT#AWC#BLJ#CCC#CTC#CurLR#ICC#ILR (Madhya Pradesh)#INSC#JLJ#LW#MANU#MhLJ#MLJ#MPLJ#MWN#OLR#RCR (Civil)#RD#SCC#SCJ#SCRAshok Bhushan,Cooperative Societies#Cooperative SocietiesSUPREME COURT OF INDIA2020-9-1821329,21331,82574,82567,82572,82541,82542,82569,82573 -->

MANU/SC/0694/2020

True Court CopyTM English

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

Civil Appeal Nos. 3195-3196 of 2020 (Arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 10972-10973 of 2020)

Decided On: 17.09.2020

Appellants: Trustees of H.C. Dhanda Trust Vs. Respondent: State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors.

Hon'ble Judges/Coram:
Ashok Bhushan, R. Subhash Reddy and M.R. Shah

JUDGMENT

Ashok Bhushan, J.

1. Leave granted.

2. The Appellant by these appeals challenges the judgment of learned Single Judge of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Bench at Indore in Writ Petition No. 8888 of 2011 dated 30.03.2017 dismissing the Writ Petition of the Appellant as well as the judgment dated 04.09.2017 of the Division Bench dismissing the Writ Appeal filed by the Appellant against the judgment of the learned Single Judge. The Division Bench has dismissed the writ appeal vide its judgment dated 04.09.2017 holding it as not maintainable.

3. Brief facts of the case giving rise to these appeals are:

Late Shri Harish Chand Dhanda, a Minister in erstwhile Government of Maharaja Holkar of Indore received the free gift of land measuring 108,900 sq.ft. (one lac eight thousand nine hundred) situate at Yeshwant Niwas Road, Indore by Order No. 58 of 22.04.1946. Late Shri H.C. Dhanda got constructed in the above piece of land, a building known as 'Hotel Lantern'. Another piece of land situate at 5, Ravindra Nath Tagore Marg, Indore was gifted to Late Shri H.C. Dhanda by his father-in-law late Col. V.B. Jadhav on 05.10.1948. Late Shri H.C. Dhanda possessed various other movable and immovable properties in the city of Indore with which we are not concerned in the present appeals. Late Shri H.C. Dhanda executed his last Will dated 26.10.2002. In his Will he mentioned his movable and immovable properties apart from the above two immovable properties and by his Will he created a Trust in which he appointed his son, Yogesh Dhanda as Chairman of Trust, Shri B.J. Dave, Chartered Accountant, Indore and one Shri Chhaganlal Nagar as member. The above two immovable properties apart from other properties were put in Trust under the aforesaid Will. All Trustees under the Will were the executors of the Will. Shri H.C. Dhanda died on 05.07.2003.

4. A meeting of Board of Trustees was held on 06.04.2005. A resolution was passed by Executors/Trustees to transfer and vest area by executing a Deed of Transfer with a site plan from the trustees to beneficiaries by registering the same. On 21.04.2005 a Deed of Assent was executed b........